Breaking News

ZTop Home

Fountain of Life Church Splits Over Leadership: Rival Groups Claim to Speak for the Board as Jimmy Odukoya Rejects Removal

A leadership dispute has split The Fountain of Life Church in Lagos. On Tuesday, November 17, 2026, a group of trustees announced that Pastor Jimmy Odukoya was no longer recognised as Senior Pastor, with immediate effect. Hours later, Mr Odukoya and the church’s official accounts rejected the announcement as constitutionally invalid. The trustees then reaffirmed the removal and named an interim leader. Nobody has proven who holds lawful authority, and we found no court action yet.

Two Statements, One Church, and No Agreement on Who Holds Authority

The first statement came from trustees who said they had reviewed the church’s constitution and the late founder’s recorded instructions. They said they wanted to carry out the succession plan Pastor Taiwo Odukoya made before his death in August 2023. In reply, a joint statement on Jimmy’s verified Instagram page and the church’s official account said the announcement came from a group calling itself “Concerned Members of the Board”. It said these trustees were asked to resign on March 14, 2026, over repeated violations of the constitution, and that one later did. It also said Jimmy remains Senior Pastor and Chairman of the Board, having been unanimously appointed in September 2023.

Premium Times noted that both statements were unsigned. Neither side has disclosed how many trustees the church has, who they are, or which constitutional provisions it relies on. Jimmy’s sister, Pastor Tolu Odukoya-Ijogun, confirmed to the paper that the first document was a valid statement from the board, but she declined to comment further.

The Trustees’ Case: A Recording, a Named Successor and an Interim Leader

The trustees say they met on November 16 and had earlier asked Mr Odukoya to step down. They allege that after the founder’s death, Mr Odukoya told the board that his father had handed him the church’s leadership, and that the board relied on this in 2023. They claim the founder had in fact asked Jimmy to record a video in December 2021 naming a different successor. They say it was witnessed by Pastor John Odukoya and was not shown to the trustees until late December 2025, long after the appointment. These are the trustees’ allegations. They have not been tested.

The trustees also said they named Pastor Rotimi Okpaise to lead the church on an interim basis. They said the church’s social media channels were taken over without board approval. Some outlets say the trustees also expressed concern about Mr Odukoya’s remarriage and its public blessing, which they described as contrary to the church’s teaching. Mr Odukoya introduced his new wife to the congregation on November 1.

Arise News later published a purported video of the founder, reportedly released by the trustees. In it, he says the next pastor should be Kunle Areogun and that Jimmy should be his immediate assistant in administration. He also says the instruction relates to a part of the church constitution that was being reworked and had not been finished. We have not independently verified the video. It is also not clear why the trustees named Mr Okpaise, not Mr Areogun, as interim leader.

Jimmy Odukoya’s Reply: Authority, Appointment and Questions Left Unanswered

Mr Odukoya’s side rests on process. It says the trustees behind the announcement lack the authority to remove him and that his 2023 appointment stands. Reports say his reply did not directly address the recording or his remarriage. That does not mean he accepts the claims, and it does not mean he rejects them. We found no statement from him on those two points. His side should be allowed to respond in full.

Church Leadership Fights in Nigeria’s Past and How Courts Treated Them

Nigerian courts have handled such disputes before. In Owodunni v Registered Trustees of Celestial Church of Christ, the Supreme Court held that a successor chosen by trustees after the founder’s death was invalid because the choice did not follow the church’s constitution. This shows that a church’s own written rules can decide the outcome.

After TB Joshua died in 2021, a succession battle followed at the Synagogue Church of All Nations. His widow was not a trustee, and her supporters obtained a court order making her one. Other handovers have gone smoothly. Margaret Idahosa took over the Church of God Mission after her husband Benson Idahosa died in 1998. When Fountain of Life named a new leader in 2023, the Guardian reported criticism that large churches were becoming family businesses.

Unwritten Wishes, Unfinished Constitutions and Missing Records: The Roots of the Standoff

Several factors can fuel a fight like this. The founder’s own words in the purported video suggest his succession clause was still being reworked. If true, the written constitution and the recorded wish may not match. A recording made years before a death may raise questions about who held it, who saw it and when.

Information gaps make it worse. The trustees say the recording reached them only in late 2025, and Mr Odukoya’s side has not said when it knew of it. Without agreed records, each side can claim the other broke the rules. This is why independent checking of documents matters.

Beyond One Congregation: Governance, Trust and the Role of the Law

The dispute touches many people. Fountain of Life is a large congregation with schools, programmes and staff. A split can hurt members’ trust and unsettle the services they depend on. Online claims about the church’s social media accounts show how quickly a private dispute can become public.

There are lessons for the country too. A critic in the Guardian argued that if Corporate Affairs Commission and Financial Reporting Council rules were properly applied, boards of trustees would work as the law intends. Public confidence in religious bodies depends on clear rules, honest records and fair treatment of leaders and members. When two groups both claim to speak for a church, the law and an open process matter most.

Balancing Respect for a Founder’s Wishes Against Fair Procedure and Member Voice

There are strong points on both sides. Those who support the trustees’ view say a founder’s clear wishes should guide a church, and that a leader who withheld key information should answer for it. Many members admire the founder and want his wishes honoured.

Those who support Mr Odukoya’s view say rules must be followed in the same way for everyone. A decision to remove a Senior Pastor, they argue, needs a valid meeting, valid trustees and a fair hearing. Members also have a stake. The question is not only what the founder wanted, but whether the church’s constitution lets a recording override a written rule, and who decides that.

Practical Ways Forward for a Divided Church

Both sides can start by publishing the constitution and the list of current trustees, so members and the public can see who holds authority. A neutral panel of respected elders, lawyers or clergy can review the recording, its origin and its fit with the constitution. If the sides cannot agree, they can seek a ruling from the courts, as past cases show.

Meanwhile, church leaders on both sides can avoid statements that inflame members. Social media accounts should be controlled by agreed rules until the dispute is settled. Members can ask for documents and facts, and can avoid rumours. Other churches can learn from this by writing their succession plans clearly and keeping records safe.

Unity Is Rebuilt on Honest Records and Open Conversation

We sympathise with a congregation caught between two statements. For many members, this is not only a legal question. It is about faith, family and the memory of founders they loved.

We cannot say who is right. The claims on each side have not been tested, and neither side has shown its documents. We believe the fairest path is an open process that checks the facts, hears every party and respects the church’s own rules. Our churches serve our society best when they handle conflict with honesty and care. We hope this one will find peace soon.

 

 

 

 

 

Published by Ejoh Caleb 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.